Home | The Whistleblower | False Claims Act | Qui Tam Litigation | Whistleblower Blog | Whistleblower Attorneys | Contact

One of the nation’s leading dialysis services companies will pay $350 million to resolve claims that it paid illegal kickbacks to physicians and physician groups in an effort to boost patient referrals. The Justice Department announced today that it had reached the settlement agreement with DaVita Healthcare Partners, Inc., which has dialysis clinics in 46 states and Washington D.C.

davitalogonew_300The settlement resolves claims initially filed by whistleblower David Barbetta, who worked for DaVita as a Senior Financial Analyst in the company’s Mergers and Acquisitions Department. Mr. Barbetta will receive a share of the settlement amount, though the exact portion has not yet been determined.

The government claims that between March 2005 and February 2014, DaVita identified physicians and physician groups with large renal disease patient populations and offered them partnership interests in DaVita’s dialysis clinics in return for referring patients. DaVita used a three-prong approach in perpetrating this alleged fraud:

  • DaVita would identify physicians or a physician group they considered a “winning practice” in a specific area. A “winning practice” could mean that the physicians were young and in debt, leading DaVita to assume that most, if not all of the physicians’ patients would be referred to DaVita clinics.
  • Once DaVita targeted a practice, they would offer them a lucrative opportunity to enter into a joint venture in which DaVita would either acquire an interest in a dialysis center owned by the practice, or DaVita would sell interest in one of its dialysis centers to the practice. In some cases, the Justice Department maintains that DaVita was able to manipulate the value of clinics it was selling interest in, which allowed the practice DaVita partnered with to realize exceedingly high returns, all but ensuring that the practices would refer patients to DaVita.
  • DaVita paid doctors they partnered with to serve as medical directors on the joint venture clinics. DaVita also used non-compete agreements with all of the practices it partnered with, ensuring that the practices could not send business to competing dialysis clinics.

As part of the settlement, DaVita agreed to a $39 million civil forfeiture based on two specific joint ventures in Denver, Colorado. The company has also entered into a Corporate Integrity Agreement with the Office of the Inspector General, which requires some business arrangements to be changed or restructured.


The Justice Department announced last week that a Florida-based radiology billing company will pay nearly $2 million to settle claims that it knowingly changed billing codes to Medicare and Medicaid in order to get previously rejected claims paid out. The settlement resolves a whistleblower claim filed by relator, Katlisa N. Vaughn, who will receive a share of the recoveries for her role in exposing the fraud.

usa-dollar-bills-1431130-mMedicare and Medicaid have guidelines stating that neither will pay for certain procedure s that are provided to patients with specific diagnoses. In an effort to avoid these restrictions, Vaughn claims that Medical Business Service, Inc. changed the codes for claims that Medicare and Medicaid had previously rejected. The alleged fraud took place between 2008 and 2010.

According to the FBI, the federal government will receive $1.917 million, with the states of Texas, New York, Florida and Georgia splitting much of the remaining portion. Vaughn will also receive a whistleblower reward, though the amount has not yet been revealed.

Since 2009, the Justice Department has recovered over $20 billion from False Claims Act cases. This case demonstrates the need for whistleblowers to come forward and expose health care fraud. If you have information concerning health care fraud at your place of work, it is in your best interest to contact an experienced whistleblower attorney to discuss your case. If your information leads to the successful recovery of government funds, you may be entitled to compensation.

Government Intervenes in Defense Company Whistleblower Lawsuit

October 16, 2014

The Justice Department announced today that it has intervened in a whistleblower lawsuit accusing Sikorsky Aircraft Corporation and subsidiaries Sikorsky Support Services Inc. and Derco Aerospace Inc. of overcharging the U.S. Navy on aircraft maintenance costs by using an illegal subcontract. The lawsuit claims that Sikorsky approved an illegal subcontract called a “cost-plus-a-percentage” contract in [...]

Read the full article →

Organon Settles False Claims Allegations for $34 Million

October 15, 2014

Organon, a pharmaceutical company with assets now owned by Merck, has agreed to pay $34 million to settle false claims allegations filed by two whistleblowers. The settlement resolves claims that Organon promoted the off label use of antidepressants, provided improper financial incentives to “nursing home pharmacy companies” and made misstatements about drug pricing which caused [...]

Read the full article →

DRS Technical Services to Pay $13.7 Million to Resolve Fraud Allegations

October 7, 2014

DRS Technical Services Inc. (DRS) will pay the government $13.7 million to settle fraud allegations, the Justice Department announced today. DRS, a Virginia-based subsidiary of DRS Defense Solutions LLC, provides a variety of wireless network solutions, security systems and telecommunication services for both the government and the private sector. The Defense Department awarded time and [...]

Read the full article →

Glaxo Investigating Corruption Allegations in the United Arab Emirates

October 6, 2014

Pharmaceutical giant GlaxoSmithKline (GSK) announced on Monday that they are looking into allegations of corruption in the United Arab Emirates. The announcement comes roughly a month after the drugmaker was hit with a $489 million fine for corruption charges in China. Reuters got wind of the corruption allegations through an anonymous email purportedly sent by [...]

Read the full article →

Caremark to Pay $6 Million to Settle Whistleblower Allegations

September 29, 2014

The pharmacy benefit management company (PBM) operated by CVS Caremark Corporation will pay $6 million to settle whistleblower allegations of fraud. Whistleblower Donald Well, a former manager at Caremark LLC, accused his former employer of knowingly failing to reimburse Medicaid for prescription drug costs paid on behalf of “dual eligible” Medicaid beneficiaries. A person is [...]

Read the full article →

Attorney General Eric Holder Says Bigger Rewards Needed for Financial Whistleblowers

September 23, 2014

U.S. Attorney General Eric Holder would like to see the government boost rewards given to whistleblowers in the financial sector who come forward with inside information on corporate wrongdoing. Holder gave a speech last week at New York University in which he called the current maximum payout for a financial whistleblower under the Financial Institutions [...]

Read the full article →

Securities and Exchange Commission Announces Largest Whistleblower Reward to Date

September 22, 2014

The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) announced today that a whistleblower will receive a $30 million reward for providing valuable information that led to a successful enforcement action. The action in question and the whistleblower’s identity have not been made public, though the SEC noted Monday that the reward was the fourth for an international [...]

Read the full article →

Detroit Doctor Admits to Administering Chemotherapy to Patients Who Didn’t Need the Treatment

September 16, 2014

A Detroit doctor is facing a statutory maximum of 175 years in jail for administering unnecessary chemotherapy to patients and submitting false claims to government health care agencies and private health insurance companies. Dr. Farid Fata of Oakland Township, Michigan today pleaded guilty before U.S. District Judge Paul Borman for his role in a health [...]

Read the full article →